What ecash is
Ecash is a balance of digital notes issued by a mint that holds bitcoin on your behalf. The notes are signed with blind signatures, so the mint can check that a note is genuine when it is spent but cannot tell which issue it came from.
David Chaum described blind signatures in a paper published in 1983. His illustration uses a carbon-lined envelope: you seal a slip inside, the signer signs the outside, and the carbon copies the signature onto the slip without the signer ever seeing it. In ecash, your wallet blinds a secret, the mint signs it, and your wallet removes the blinding. The result is a valid note the mint has never seen.
When a note is spent, the mint records it so it cannot be spent twice. What it cannot do is link that spend to the moment it signed the note. Bitcoin Optech sums up the trade: the mint cannot see who holds what, and everyone has to trust the mint to store the money.
Chaum: blind signatures for untraceable payments ↗ · Bitcoin Optech: ecash ↗
Cashu: one operator per mint
Cashu is an open protocol for Chaumian ecash on Bitcoin. Each mint is run by a single operator, and anyone can run one. The rules are written as a set of numbered specifications called NUTs. Wallets and mints must implement the mandatory ones, and the rest are optional.
- Getting in. You ask the mint for ecash, it gives you a Lightning invoice, and once you pay it, the mint signs your blinded notes.
- Getting out. You hand the mint a Lightning invoice and enough notes to cover it, and the mint pays the invoice. Cashu calls this melting.
- Paying another Cashu user. Notes can be passed on as a token, a string of text starting cashuB. Whoever holds the token can redeem it, so treat it like cash.
- One mint at a time. Each mint issues its own notes. A token from one mint cannot be received into another, so moving between mints goes through Lightning.
The notes live in your wallet's storage. Cashu's own FAQ warns that if that storage is wiped, the funds are lost.
Cashu docs ↗ · Cashu NUTs ↗ · NUT-04 ↗ · NUT-05 ↗
Fedimint: a mint run by a group
Fedimint spreads the mint across a federation of guardians. Bitcoin you deposit sits in a multisignature wallet the guardians hold together, and the ecash notes are signed with threshold blind signatures, so no single guardian can issue them alone.
- On-chain in and out. You can deposit bitcoin on-chain and receive ecash, and withdraw back on-chain.
- Lightning through a gateway. A Lightning gateway, run by a federation member or anyone else, pays invoices for you and credits you when you are paid. To send, your ecash is locked in a contract the federation enforces, and the gateway can claim it only after it has paid the invoice.
- Guardians going offline. fedimint.org says the federation keeps running if a minority of guardians go offline, and pauses until enough return if a majority do.
Guardians can see the total bitcoin held and the total ecash outstanding. They cannot see individual balances or link who received a note to who redeemed it.
Fedimint: how it works ↗ · Fedimint FAQ ↗ · Fedimint: Lightning gateway ↗
Ecash is custodial
With ecash, the mint or the federation holds the bitcoin. Your notes are a claim on it, and that claim is only as good as the people behind it.
- A Cashu mint runs the Lightning node and holds the sats for all its users. Its operator can stop redeeming notes, disappear, or be shut down.
- A Fedimint federation spreads that risk across several people. Fedimint's own page calls it an explicit trust model: a majority of guardians acting together could steal the bitcoin, or issue more ecash than there is bitcoin to back it.
Neither system gives you a way to take your bitcoin back without the mint's cooperation. Both projects tell you to choose a mint or federation run by people you know and trust, and Cashu's FAQ adds that you should not put in any money you are not willing to lose.
Cashu FAQ ↗ · Fedimint: privacy and trust ↗
What it hides, and what it does not
Ecash hides your activity from the mint. There are no user accounts, and blinding stops the mint linking the notes it issued to the notes it later redeems. It does not cover the following.
- Lightning payments. To pay out, you hand the invoice to the Cashu mint or the Fedimint gateway, which then sees what it is paying. When you are paid over Lightning through a Cashu mint, its FAQ says the mint can almost certainly identify you as the receiver.
- Your internet address. The protocol does not hide it. Cashu's FAQ says the mint could see your IP address unless you use Tor, a VPN or similar.
- Small crowds. Notes come in fixed denominations. Larger amounts use rarer ones and stand out more, and a mint with few users gives you few people to hide among.
- Sending tokens. A Cashu token sent by message is readable by anyone who sees the message, and spendable by them too.
For how ecash fits into a wider privacy routine, see Your balance is a collection of stories.
Cashu FAQ ↗ · Fedimint: privacy and trust ↗
Using it
- Keep amounts small. Cashu describes itself as in early development and advises small amounts. Treat ecash as spending money.
- Choose the operator first. For Cashu, that means a mint whose operator you know and trust. For Fedimint, a federation run by people you know. The closer the relationship, the safer the funds, in Fedimint's words.
- Do not sit on tokens you are sent. Redeem them, or swap them to a mint you trust.
Wallets checked on 17 November 2026, each with a release, code change or site update from its project in October or November 2026:
- Cashu: Cashu.me (runs in a web browser), Minibits (Android and iOS) and Macadamia (iOS).
- Fedimint: Fedi (Android and iOS). fedimint.org lists other wallets, several of them marked beta.
Backups, and when a mint goes away
Cashu. Wallets that follow NUT-13 derive your notes from a 12-word recovery phrase. Restoring has limits:
- The phrase only restores ecash minted or received after the phrase was created.
- The wallet cannot find your mints for you. Keep a note of each mint's address.
- The mint has to reissue its signatures, so it must be running and support restore (NUT-09, an optional spec).
Fedimint. Wallets derive notes from a root secret and store encrypted backups with the guardians. Recovery rebuilds your notes from that backup and the federation's history, so the federation has to be running. fedimint.org says the exact process depends on your wallet app and federation, so check what yours asks you to keep.
If the mint disappears. Neither design has a way to reach the bitcoin without the mint. A Cashu mint that goes offline cannot redeem your notes, and a federation with most guardians gone is paused. Move your balance out while the operator is still running. In November 2026 the Fedi app's download page was already asking users in some federations to move their funds, because guardians were migrating to a newer setup.
NUT-13 ↗ · Fedimint: backup and recovery ↗
How it compares
| Ecash (Cashu, Fedimint) | Custodial Lightning wallet | Ark and Spark | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds the bitcoin | The mint, or the federation's guardians together. | The wallet company. | Your claim sits in transactions you can broadcast, with an operator involved while things run normally. |
| What the operator sees | Total funds, and Lightning invoices it pays. Not who holds which notes. | An account in your name, with your balance and payments. | See the Ark or Spark comparison. |
| Leaving without the operator | Not possible. | Not possible. | Possible, slowly and with on-chain fees. |
| If the operator vanishes | The notes cannot be redeemed. | The balance cannot be withdrawn. | You can exit alone, if you have the data and fees. |
The full detail is in the Ark and Spark guides. For a Lightning setup without a custodian, see Choose the Lightning setup you can maintain.
Sources & further reading
Researched 17 November 2026. Software and services change: check the current documents before you act.
- David Chaum: Blind signatures for untraceable payments (1983) ↗
- Bitcoin Optech: ecash ↗
- Cashu docs ↗
- Cashu docs: protocol ↗
- Cashu docs: FAQ ↗
- Cashu NUTs ↗
- NUT-00: cryptography and models ↗
- NUT-04: minting tokens ↗
- NUT-05: melting tokens ↗
- NUT-13: deterministic secrets ↗
- Fedimint: how it works ↗
- Fedimint: privacy and trust ↗
- Fedimint: FAQ ↗
- Fedimint: wallets ↗
- Fedimint repository ↗
- Fedimint docs: architecture ↗
- Fedimint docs: Lightning gateway ↗
- Fedimint docs: backup and recovery ↗
- Cashu.me repository ↗
- Minibits ↗
- Minibits repository ↗
- Macadamia repository ↗
- Fedi: get the app ↗
Ark or Spark? → · Ark → · Spark → · Choose the Lightning setup you can maintain → · Lightning, without the surprises → · Your balance is a collection of stories →
