A transaction ledger and receipt examined separately, editorial illustration
Privacy / ORIGINAL WALKTHROUGH

CoinJoin Change Outputs

How CoinJoin change can reveal connections, and how to make deliberate decisions about spending it.

Start reading
2 min read4 imagesEnglishOriginal page ↗
READING MODE

What is CoinJoin change?

In the historical Whirlpool workflow, a preparation transaction called Tx0 created outputs for mixing and returned the remainder as change. That change did not pass through the equal-output mix. “Doxxic change” was the community’s name for it; the term describes a privacy concern, not a special kind of bitcoin.

The change remains connected to the preparation transaction and its inputs. Combining it with postmix outputs creates new evidence about their relationship. That can reduce the privacy benefit of mixing, without proving that every earlier or later transaction belongs to one person.

Watch Coinjoin, explained in 2 minutes. Captions available.
01 / Tx0 change
The remainder keeps its history.
Historical example
Inputs
Deposit
1.03 BTC
Outputs
Premix
0.5 BTC
Premix
0.5 BTC
Change
0.03 BTC

A preparation transaction separates pool-sized outputs from the remainder. That change remains linked to the funding inputs. Simplified amounts omit fees.

Reference ↗
02 / Combining outputs
Separate histories can meet again.
Inputs
Postmix output
Linked change
Outputs
Combined spend

Spending these outputs together creates a visible relationship. Review their labels and origins before combining them; a previous mix does not prevent later links.

Reference ↗

Start with labels and coin control

Identify the output and label where it came from. If your wallet supports freezing or marking an output “do not spend”, use that to prevent accidental selection while you decide. This is a wallet setting, not an on-chain restriction, and it may not survive a recovery into different software.

The screenshot below records the old Samourai interface. Do not assume that its account separation or automatic protections exist in another wallet. Inspect the actual transaction inputs before signing.

FIG. 03Start with labels and coin controlStart with labels and coin control

Combining change creates a link

Combining change outputs makes their shared participation visible. Even if each came from a different preparation transaction, consolidation can help an observer connect those histories. Keep them separate when that connection matters; there is no universally private consolidation recipe.

04 / Consolidation
Two pieces become one.
Inputs
Change A
0.03 BTC
Change B
0.02 BTC
Outputs
Combined output
0.05 BTC

Consolidation reduces the number of UTXOs but connects their histories. Sharing an origin does not make every merge private. Simplified amounts omit fees.

Reference ↗

Historical mixing options

The original guide suggested smaller Whirlpool pools or Stowaway transactions. Those were features of a particular service and wallet stack. Samourai’s infrastructure was seized in April 2024, and Sparrow removed its Whirlpool client in 1.9.0. These suggestions are historical, not a current service recommendation.

Spending, swapping or donating

A gift-card purchase, swap, donation or Lightning channel does not automatically erase an output’s history. A service may retain account, payment or network records, and a recipient may identify you. Consider those disclosures alongside custody, fees and refund requirements before choosing where to spend.

There is no need to rush an irreversible transfer just to remove a label from your wallet. Keep recovery information and labels intact, decide which connections matter, and review the complete transaction. The privacy question is what a particular observer can learn, not whether the coins have become “clean”.

Continue your path

One question leads to another.

01Your balance is a collection of stories02Make privacy a routine

Find your next answer.

Search the complete field guide · Esc to close